Noise Blockers vs Noise Absorbers
For soundproofing solutions, do you want noise absorbers or noise blockers? Here's how to tell the difference.
There are many materials and products recommended for noise control or sound treatment. However, different materials affect sound in different ways, and it's important to know what they are good for, so you can select the best materials for your project. The biggest source of confusion is the difference between sound blocking and sound absorption. If you understand this difference, you can avoid wasting time, money, and effort on products that will not accomplish what you want.
Sound Blocking vs Sound Absorption
is what you want when your goal is to prevent sound from entering or leaving a room or a building. This is what we normally mean when we talk about soundproofing. Examples are:
- You want to block traffic noise from entering your house.
- You want to avoid hearing the music from the neighbor's apartment.
- You want a quiet room in your home where you can concentrate on your work.
- You want to avoid disturbing the neighbors when someone in your family plays a musical instrument.
is what you want when the goal is to reduce the sound bouncing around inside a room, causing echoes and reverberations. The key is this: The source of the sound is in the same room with the listener. Examples are:
- You have a loft apartment where voices echo and sound hollow, and you want to soften it so that voices sound more warm and natural.
- A restaurant manager wants to reduce the noise of clattering dishes in the dining area.
- A lecture hall needs to have minimal reverberation so that the speaker can be heard clearly from any seat.
- A recording studio needs to control sound reflections, to preserve the clarity of the sound being produced and recorded.
Related to sound absorption is sound diffusion
. These two techniques are used in tandem to optimize the acoustics within a given space (acoustical room treatment
), according to the purpose and individual characteristics of the room.
How to Tell What a Product Is Designed for
When you're looking at a potential soundproofing product, how can you tell whether it is designed for sound blocking or for acoustical room treatment? It's not always obvious from the way the material is advertised. Both types of material may be billed as noise reduction products or sound treatment products, or even as soundproofing products. Here are three ways to tell:
- Look at the
- If the product specifications include a sound transmission class (STC) number, a transmission loss (TL) curve, or a weighted sound reduction index value, the product was tested as a sound blocking material.
- If the specs include a noise reduction coefficient (NRC) or a weighted sound absorption coefficient, the product was tested as a sound absorbing material.
- If no test data is available for the product, that means any advertising claims made for the effectiveness of the product are unsupported.
- Look at the words used to describe the product. Although not always reliable, it can still give you a clue.
- Sound blocking materials may be described as noise blockers or noise barriers, or as preventing the transmission of sound.
- Descriptions of noise absorbers may discuss acoustic treatment or acoustic conditioning, for reduction, absorption, or diffusion of reflected sound, echoes, and reverberation.
- Look at the material itself.
- Panels of sound blocking material are usually quite heavy.
- Noise absorbers tend to be light, soft, and/or porous.
Sometimes Both Are Appropriate
Sound blocking and sound absorption applications are not mutually exclusive. For some projects, both techniques will be needed.
The Role of Absorption in Soundproofing
If you're familiar with the
basic principles of soundproofing,
you know that absorption is indeed one of the four basic soundproofing elements, albeit the element with the weakest effect. Does that mean that acoustic treatment products can contribute to effective soundproofing? Not quite. Here's the difference: When used for acoustic treatment, absorptive materials are installed as exposed surfaces within the room. But when used for soundproofing, the place for absorption is within a closed space such as within a wall, where standard fiberglass insulation, loosely packed, can serve to absorb sound that would otherwise get bounced between the wall panels.
The Role of Soundproofing in Acoustic Treatment
When constructing or enhancing a sound recording studio or rehearsal studio, both acoustic treatment and soundproofing techniques will be needed. Soundproofing will keep out noise coming from outside the studio, and acoustic treatment (noise absorbers and/or diffusers) will preserve the desired clarity of the sound being produced.
Materials used in soundproofing
Leave this page (Noise Blockers vs Noise Absorbers) and go → Back to Soundproofing Walls, Floors, & Ceilings
Leave this page (Noise Blockers vs Noise Absorbers) and go → Back to Noise Help home page